Canada’s response to the COVID-19 pandemic has been uneven: A federal framework, mixed with a patchwork of provincial and territorial methods, created most of the identical challenges the nation’s well being care system has been by in years previous. Examples embody the 2003 SARS (extreme acute respiratory syndrome) outbreak and the contaminated blood scandal within the early Eighties.
Medical consultants say the problems are systemic, provided that Canada has a decentralized well being care system that’s managed by every province and territory. However as an alternative of accepting the system for what it’s, some within the medical neighborhood are calling for a proper pan-Canadian strategy to repair Canada’s immunization system for the long run.
The concept is to create a Canadian Immunization Providers group, modelled after Canadian Blood Providers (CBS), the non-profit established in 1998 in response to the foremost well being system failure that noticed almost 2,000 Canadians grow to be contaminated with HIV from tainted blood merchandise and one other 30,000 contaminated with the hepatitis C.
“Making a Canadian Immunization Providers utilizing the mannequin for the Canadian Blood Providers may deal with historic challenges associated to variability in immunization practices and sharing of information throughout Canada,” argues a paper revealed just lately within the Canadian Medical Affiliation Journal. It was written by physicians Kumanan Wilson (a medical professor and member of the Centre for Well being Legislation, Coverage and Ethics on the College of Ottawa), Graham Sher (chief govt officer of CBS) and Jane Philpott (a former MP and dean of Queen’s College School of Well being Sciences).
CBS, which is funded primarily by the federal and provincial governments, takes a nationwide strategy to equitable acquisition, distribution, stock administration and knowledge sharing to assist serve Canadians in want of blood and blood merchandise. It operates with a clear and shared lens which permits for higher provide chain administration and fast entry to experience.
It has additionally produced a safer blood system Canadians really feel they’ll rely on. Dr. Wilson acknowledges he was essential of the CBS at first, as a result of it skilled some rising pains early on, however now helps it as a solution to drive pan-Canadian collaboration.
A system that was centralized much like the CBS would’ve helped throughout SARS, Dr. Wilson says, to not point out the present COVID-19 pandemic.
“It turned obvious there was a basic failure in our means to conduct surveillance and the way the federal government interacted” throughout the SARS disaster, Dr. Wilson says. “There wasn’t a sharing of information between provinces and the federal authorities and that resulted within the journey advisory, that was in any other case avoidable.”
By way of COVID-19 vaccinations, Dr. Wilson says inconsistencies from one jurisdiction to the subsequent can create complications for Canadians. For instance, proof of vaccination varies from province to province. “We don’t have harmonization and that might grow to be a really sensible drawback as individuals transfer from province and territory,” Dr. Wilson says.
Canada performed catchup
Dr. Sher of CBS says Canada has been a laggard worldwide in terms of vaccine supply, pointing to locations like the UK as extra superior.
“Why would the U.Okay., which has a single well being care system to serve the entire nation, have the ability to entry and ship vaccines simply 8 to 12 weeks forward of Canada?” he asks.
Organizationally, he says the provincial rollouts affected the well being and security of three,500 staff at CBS. “Our front-line well being care employees in lots of instances couldn’t get equitable entry to vaccination,” Dr. Sher says. “So a nurse in Vancouver was having a really completely different probability of getting a vaccine in comparison with any person in Halifax or Charlottetown or Toronto.”
Primarily based in Ottawa, Dr. Sher skilled the identical confusion many Ontarians initially skilled, from when to get the jab to second-guessing the protection of vaccines. “On the finish of the day, [many of us are] vaccinated and that’s nice. However I feel the nation may’ve had a greater expertise,” he says.
Challenges of a centralized system
Whereas a centralized immunization system would offer advantages, Katherine Fierlbeck, a professor and chair within the division of political science at Dalhousie College, says implementation could be tough.
“In Canada, public well being providers are largely offered by the provinces and that’s primarily based on constitutional regulation. And, as that’s devilishly tough to handle, we’re largely constrained by this actuality,” Dr. Fierlbeck explains. She additionally notes there are current collaborative methods such because the Nationwide Advisory Committee on Immunization, an advisory physique that makes vaccine suggestions, and the Immunization Partnership Fund, a federal service that helps enhance entry to vaccines.
“There have been constant makes an attempt to ascertain linkages between jurisdictions, however they do fall in need of what would’ve been profitable when COVID-19 descended on us,” she says.
The timing for a brand new system may also be off, Dr. Fierlbeck provides. “The pandemic has additionally put heavy strains on provincial well being care methods, and it might even be the case that [a centralized immunization service] is seen as a luxurious that should wait.”
On Nov. 30, The Globe and Mail hosted a digital occasion referred to as Regenerative medication: The place will stem cells take us? Offered by Bayer, the webinar explored the way in which researchers are engaged on stem cell advances that might change the way forward for medication. Learn extra right here.